Nations Veile Election 2024

Williamson County Circuit Judge Erin Nations (left) and Franklin attorney David Veile (right)

Williamson County will elect its newest circuit court judge this year, with Franklin attorney David Veile challenging current Williamson County circuit Judge Erin Nations, who was appointed to the bench last year by Gov. Bill Lee.

Nations was sworn in to the interim position in November 2023 following the retirement of Judge Michael Binkley.

“The very next day I was up here at the courthouse, looking at case files, getting right down to business, and starting hearing cases,” Nations told The News.

“Initially, I decided to seek this position because I think good judges are really, really important to a good healthy community, which we have here,” Nations said. “I'm trying to fulfill that mission.”

Nations is the second “Judge Nations” in Williamson County, sharing that title with her father-in-law, retired Judge Al Nations.

Veile also interviewed for the appointment, and both he and Nations said in 2023 that they planned to run for the seat regardless of who was ultimately appointed to the bench.

“While I understand that I did not receive the temporary political appointment, I am running full speed ahead to show the voters of Williamson County why I'm the best candidate to serve as circuit court judge,” Veile said.

Although Veile did not receive the appointment, he did receive an endorsement from the Morris Heithcock Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 41, a designation he called “huge.”

“The police have been willing to stand up beside me and say 'when you're looking for the right judge, that candidate is David Veile,'” he said.

Nations downplayed the impact of the FOP endorsement and the need for endorsements in general, telling The News “I don't really find that to be appropriate in a judicial race.”

“The first tenant of being a judge is to maintain fairness and impartiality, and accepting an endorsement from any entity could potentially put you in a situation where it may look to the public like you are not fair and impartial if someone having anything to do with that entity happens to appear in your courtroom at any given time,” Nations said.

Veile told The News that his experience as both a police officer and a seasoned criminal defense attorney has prepared him for the job, specifically pointing to his recent representation in a high-profile case involving a Nashville security guard who was acquitted of murder following a 2018 shooting.

“Fairly early on into my practice, I felt the calling that I would be a good person on the bench and using the experience I had both as a law enforcement officer and as the law instructor at the police academy,” Veile said. 

“Coupled with the now 19 years of trial court experience as a trial attorney, to be able to listen to a case not from any one position, but from the perspective of the law, and then rule fairly under the law, while treating people kindly and treating the way that I would want to be treated if I were a litigant in the courtroom.”

Nations previously served as a Williamson County Commissioner, and in addition to her months-long experience on the bench, Nations touts her prior experience as a law clerk, as a criminal defense and family and domestic lawyer, as well as two stints as an appointed special magistrate, all of which she said sets her apart in the race.

“I'm here; I'm doing the job,” Nations said. “I'm familiar with the cases and I think it also gives me the advantage that the public to some extent, and certainly the bar, the attorneys of the bar, have now experienced what I'm going to be like as a judge.”

Both candidates call themselves “Constitutional conservatives” and support some alternative sentencing programs like Williamson County's recovery court, but both have said they're committed to upholding the Constitution.

“I think that the Constitution, the laws of the state of Tennessee should be applied to the facts of every case, as they have been written. There should be no legislating from the bench and no manipulating the letter of the law to fit the outcome that the judge personally might desire,” Nations said.

“I lived it, initially, as an officer,” Veile said. “I was the officer standing outside the door with a gun in my hand, having to make a split second decision under the Constitution, under the Fourth Amendment; Do I have the authority and the responsibility and duty to make entry into this house? Is this search illegal? Is it justified, either through a search warrant or through an exception to the search warrant?

"That grew when I was law instructor at the police academy, and it was my responsibility to instruct the very people that are charged to protect the public to make sure that they did what they did within constitutional constraints.”

There has been some dispute between the candidates on their background, with Veile telling The News that he is “the only candidate that has tried jury trials, both in civil court and in criminal court,” and Nations saying that she has “tried cases representing clients all the way through trial” in her 15-year legal career. 

The News could not independently verify the detailed extent of either candidate's time in the courtroom.

Early voting will take place from Feb. 14-27 with the primary election set for March 5. More information about voting in Williamson County can be found here.