Nations Veile Election 2024

Williamson County Circuit Judge Erin Nations (left) and Franklin attorney David Veile (right)

Williamson County's judicial race continues to heat up in the hours before Election Day, with one sitting circuit judge speaking out against a campaign ad by candidate and sitting Judge Erin Nations.

The most recent controversy was sparked following a mobile ad from the campaign for Judge Erin Nations, who was appointed to the circuit court bench last year and is running for the seat against lawyer David Veile.

Read more about both candidate's platforms here.

That campaign ad, which can be seen below, reads in part, “David Veile has built a career defending child rapists and violent criminals,” calling him “soft on crime.”

Erin Nations campaign ad David Veile

2024 campaign ad for judicial candidate Erin Nations 

The ad was met with some public outcry from lawyers and others, with some defense attorneys, who did not want to be publicly identified, telling The News that they are concerned that the ad could undermine Nation's judicial impartiality, especially as she is currently serving on the bench.

On Saturday, Veile addressed the ad in a social media post, writing, “My opponent is desperately trying to save her sinking campaign and cover up her gross inexperience, stooping to outright lies.”

The election drama became apparent on Feb. 26, when Veile was the only candidate to attend a judicial forum hosted by the Williamson County Bar Association, of which he previously served as president. Nations told The News that she never committed to taking part in the event and called WCBA's statements and actions in advertising and hosting the forum “misleading.”

Criticism of Nations’ campaign ad increased on Monday when her colleague, Williamson County Circuit Judge Joseph Woodruff wrote a letter voicing his concerns about the ad.

In that letter addressed to WCBA President Brittany Bartkowaik, and obtained by The News, Woodruff said that some lawyers are “justifiably disturbed” by the ad. The letter can be read in full below.

Erin Nations 2024 judge Woodruff letter

March 4, 2024, letter from Williamson County Circuit Judge Joseph Woodruff criticizing a campaign ad by the campaign of fellow Judge Erin Nations.

“The ad is premised on the odious proposition that criminal defense lawyers share the moral turpitude of their clients,” Woodruff wrote. “This idea is abhorrent to the legal profession, and an anathema to the rights of the accused guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment.”

Woodruff said that the letter is not an endorsement or in opposition of either candidate, adding, “the purpose of this letter is to reassure the Williamson County bar, as the currently serving presiding judge, that the advertisement does not represent my views, and I would hope does not represent the views of the rest of the judiciary,” Woodruff wrote in part.

“I feel compelled to do so lest my silence be misunderstood as approval of a campaign tactic that has no place in a judicial election.”

While Woodruff may not be publicly endorsing any candidate, the letter and the ad that sparked it could impact undecided voters when they head to the polls for Tuesday's primary election.

A representative from Nations' campaign replied to a request for comment from The News with the following statement.

"In a judicial election, voters are asked to make a choice between candidates, based on a number of factors including their legal backgrounds. Williamson County voters have a choice between Judge Erin Nations, who has a proven career practicing law that keeps families safe and David Veile who built his career making excuses for violent criminals."

According to the Williamson County Election Commission, 14,195 votes were cast diuring early voting from Feb. 14-27, which is just 7.5% of registered voters.

Polls are open from 7 a.m.-7 p.m. on Tuesday, March 5, with more information about where to vote available online here.